• About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Pragativadi I Latest Odisha News in English I Breaking News
  • EPAPER
  • Odisha
  • Twin City
  • Politics
  • National
  • World
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Tech
  • Education
No Result
View All Result
  • EPAPER
  • Odisha
  • Twin City
  • Politics
  • National
  • World
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Tech
  • Education
No Result
View All Result
Pragativadi I Latest Odisha News in English I Breaking News
No Result
View All Result

Home » Six BJD Cross-Voting MLAs Label Show-Cause Notice Illegal, Threaten Criminal Case Against Chief Whip

Six BJD Cross-Voting MLAs Label Show-Cause Notice Illegal, Threaten Criminal Case Against Chief Whip

Cross-Voting MLAs Defy Party, Cite Supreme Court Precedents in Bold Reversal Over Rajya Sabha Poll Dissent

Yajati Rout by Yajati Rout
March 20, 2026
in Odisha, Politics, Trending Now
Reading Time: 2 mins read
0 0
0
72
VIEWS

In a dramatic escalation within the Biju Janata Dal (BJD), six MLAs accused of cross-voting in the recent Rajya Sabha elections have rejected the party’s show-cause notice as “illegal, arbitrary, and unconstitutional,” while issuing a stern counter-warning to Chief Whip Pramila Mallik of potential criminal prosecution.


The controversy stems from the March 16 Rajya Sabha polls, where several BJD MLAs reportedly voted against the party’s official candidates, including in favour of BJP-backed independent Dilip Ray. On March 17, Chief Whip Pramila Mallik issued show-cause notices to six legislators—**Devi Ranjan Tripathy** (Banki), **Souvic Biswal** (Choudwar-Cuttack), **Chakramani Kanhar** (Baliguda), **Subasini Jena** (Basta), **Naba Kishor Mallick** (Jayadev), and **Ramakanta Bhoi** (Tirtol)—demanding explanations by 5 PM on March 20 for what the party termed a “grave breach of discipline” and “betrayal of trust.”

In their replies, submitted before the deadline, the MLAs—led prominently by Devi Ranjan Tripathy—dismissed the notice outright. They described it as “baseless, whimsical, and aimed at intimidating” them to influence future elections unlawfully. Tripathy’s response explicitly warned that the notice violates Supreme Court precedents, particularly the landmark **Kuldip Nayar vs Union of India (2006)** ruling, which held that no party whip can bind MLAs in Rajya Sabha elections, as these do not attract disqualification under the Tenth Schedule (anti-defection law). The MLAs also referenced the **Kihoto Hollohan** case and Election Commission directives from 2017 affirming free voting conscience in such indirect elections.

Citing provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2003—Sections 171 (undue influence at elections) and 174 (non-compliance with lawful orders)—Tripathy and others accused Mallik of overstepping her authority and committing a cognizable offense through intimidation. They demanded immediate withdrawal of the notice, failing which they vowed to file criminal complaints.

The MLAs further argued that no explicit whip was issued to them during a March 15 party meeting, and cross-voting reflected their independent judgment without breaching the party constitution or voluntarily giving up membership. They rejected allegations of anti-party activity or resignation.

In response, Pramila Mallik dismissed the replies as coordinated and typed from a single office, suggesting external orchestration. “They signed it, but why hide the truth about why they voted against the party?” she said. “The party is filtering out impurities; let the law take its course if they choose that path.”

The episode highlights growing internal rifts in the BJD following its reduced influence post-2024 elections, with rebels asserting constitutional freedoms over party directives in Rajya Sabha polls.

Legal experts note that while anti-defection provisions do not apply to Rajya Sabha voting, internal party actions could still lead to disciplinary measures short of disqualification.


 

Tags: Anti-Defection LawBJD MLAs show cause notice responseBJD rebelsBNS 171 174Devi Ranjan TripathyNaveen PatnaikOdisha Politicspramila mallikRajya Sabha cross votingshow-cause noticeSupreme Court whip ruling
Previous Post

Odisha Sets Guinness World Record for Largest Serving of Pakhala

Next Post

BJD Disciplinary Panel Meet Over Cross-Voting by 6 MLAs; Naveen to Take Final Call

Yajati Rout

Yajati Rout

Yajati K. Rout is a dynamic journalist at Pragativadi, known for delivering nuanced and impactful storytelling that spans Odisha’s societal fabric to global sports arenas. His reporting navigates seamlessly between grassroots realities, high-profile political developments, and the pulse of international tennis and cricket. With a flair for SEO-driven storytelling and a deep cultural lens, Yajati crafts content that resonates with a diverse readership—bridging insight with accessibility.

Related Posts

​Tamil Nadu CM Vijay Greets Rajinikanth and MK Stalin at Anirudh Ravichander and Kavya Maran’s Grand Chennai Wedding Reception
Entertainment

​Tamil Nadu CM Vijay Greets Rajinikanth and MK Stalin at Anirudh Ravichander and Kavya Maran’s Grand Chennai Wedding Reception

November 21, 2026
BJD Odisha Disaster Management
Odisha

BJD Welcomes Probe into Naveen Patnaik’s Foreign Visits, Demands Same Accountability from Mohan Majhi Govt

November 21, 2026
Odisha Household Travel Survey
Odisha

Odisha Rolls Out Mega Household Travel Survey on Nov 23 to Map Future of Regional Transit

November 21, 2026
Next Post
BJD disciplinary committee cross-voting

BJD Disciplinary Panel Meet Over Cross-Voting by 6 MLAs; Naveen to Take Final Call

Odisha Higher Education Budget 2026-27: Rs 3,664.40 Crore Passed in Assembly | ShaktiShree Yojana & 7 New Colleges

Odisha Higher Education Budget 2026-27: Rs 3,664.40 Crore Passed in Assembly | ShaktiShree Yojana & 7 New Colleges

Odisha PWD Budget 2026-27: Rs 13,451 Crore for Pothole-Free Roads, 4-Lane Upgrades & Major Corridors

Odisha PWD Budget 2026-27: Rs 13,451 Crore for Pothole-Free Roads, 4-Lane Upgrades & Major Corridors

Follow Us

  • 78.9k Followers

Recommended

Odisha Malaria Dengue Control

Odisha Health Minister Reviews Malaria and Dengue Control Measures

1 year ago
Lingaraj Temple Mishap

NHRC Demands ATR Over Lingaraj Temple Accident During Maha Shivratri

1 year ago
Baliapal police attack case

Baliapal Police Team Attacked While Arresting Kidnap Accused, 3 Women Arrested

5 months ago
Aska power supply restored

Power Back On: Aska Urban Area Reclaims Electricity After Cyclone Arnab Floods

3 weeks ago

Instagram

Follow Now

Highlights

Balangir Police Bust Major Job Fraud Racket; Repeat Offender Arrested for Duping Aspirants of ₹14 Lakh

Odisha Rolls Out Mega Household Travel Survey on Nov 23 to Map Future of Regional Transit

Yuzvendra Chahal Joins BJP, Appointed Special Invitee to OBC Morcha

​Women’s Asian Champions Trophy 2026: Defending Champions India Beat Korea 2-1 in Bhopal to Register Second Straight Win

From Odisha’s ITIs to National Glory: Four Trainees Felicitated by PM Modi

Odisha Aims 98 Lakh MT Paddy Procurement for 2026–27; Chief Secy Directs Hassle-Free Operations

Trending

Crimes against women in Bhubaneswar
Crime

330 Grams of Brown Sugar Seized in Bhubaneswar, Four Arrested in Separate Raids

by Yajati Rout
November 21, 2026
0

In a major crackdown against drug trafficking, mobile teams of the Bhubaneswar Excise Department seized a total...

​Tamil Nadu CM Vijay Greets Rajinikanth and MK Stalin at Anirudh Ravichander and Kavya Maran’s Grand Chennai Wedding Reception

​Tamil Nadu CM Vijay Greets Rajinikanth and MK Stalin at Anirudh Ravichander and Kavya Maran’s Grand Chennai Wedding Reception

November 21, 2026
BJD Odisha Disaster Management

BJD Welcomes Probe into Naveen Patnaik’s Foreign Visits, Demands Same Accountability from Mohan Majhi Govt

November 21, 2026
Balangir job fraud racket

Balangir Police Bust Major Job Fraud Racket; Repeat Offender Arrested for Duping Aspirants of ₹14 Lakh

November 21, 2026
Odisha Household Travel Survey

Odisha Rolls Out Mega Household Travel Survey on Nov 23 to Map Future of Regional Transit

November 21, 2026
Facebook Twitter Youtube RSS

ABOUT US

News, as it should be covered, has been the forte of Pragativadi over the years. And this has ensured a classy readership encompassing the who’s who of the state. The people who matter in Odisha, depend on Pragativadi. For opinion leaders, decision makers and people with surplus disposable income Pragativadi is a must.

Follow us on social media:

E-Library

Chayanika

by Yajati Rout
December 16, 2025
0

Unmesha

by Yajati Rout
December 16, 2025
0

© 2026 Pragativadi

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • EPAPER
  • Odisha
  • Twin City
  • Politics
  • National
  • World
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Tech
  • Education

© 2026 Pragativadi