The Delhi High Court has held that a woman’s father-in-law cannot be held liable under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence (DV) Act merely for failing to control the conduct of his adult son.
Justice Madhu Jain made this observation while dismissing a woman’s plea challenging a lower court order, which had earlier declined to proceed against her father-in-law on allegations of domestic violence.
The Core Verdict
The petitioner had accused her father-in-law of failing to act against her estranged husband regarding his alleged involvement with another woman. Addressing this, the court firmly stated:
“A father cannot be made liable under the DV Act merely because he did not control the conduct of his adult son.”
The court noted that while the DV Act covers various forms of abuse—including physical, mental, verbal, emotional, and economic harm—a mere domestic relationship is insufficient to attract its provisions. The petitioner failed to establish any direct role of the father-in-law in the alleged matrimonial misconduct.
Addressing Business and Commercial Disputes
Records from the August ruling also highlighted that the petitioner and her father-in-law shared a professional relationship as partners in a business firm.
While acknowledging that commercial disputes are not automatically excluded from the scope of Section 3 of the Act, the court emphasised that it must be proven that the woman was denied a legally protected resource. The bench found no evidence of any threat or act of domestic violence originating from the father-in-law.
On Vague Allegations
The High Court further dismissed broad claims made by the petitioner, noting that allegations involving terms like “insulted,” “shouted,” and “abused” were merely conclusions rather than established facts.
“The words ‘insulted’, ‘shouted’ and ‘abused’ are conclusions. Without the facts underlying them, they do not make out verbal or emotional abuse under Section 3,” the bench held.
Ultimately, the Delhi High Court upheld the lower court’s decision, ruling that there was no factual basis to link the father-in-law to the alleged acts of domestic violence.

















