In a significant ruling, the Orissa High Court observed that a wife repeatedly threatening suicide or violence is not merely marital misconduct but amounts to emotional blackmail and psychological oppression of the husband.
The court made this strong observation while upholding a family court’s decision to grant divorce on grounds of cruelty.
Case Background:
The case dates back to 2003, when the couple got married. By 2009, the husband approached the family court seeking divorce, citing mental cruelty inflicted by his wife.
He alleged that his wife frequently engaged in heated quarrels, exerted complete financial control, repeatedly threatened suicide, and even forced his elderly parents out of their home.
After hearing the arguments, the Cuttack family court granted a divorce but directed the husband to pay Rs 63 lakh as permanent alimony.
However, the wife challenged the verdict in the Orissa High Court, seeking the restoration of conjugal rights.
High Court’s Stern Observation:
Dismissing the wife’s appeal, a division bench comprising Justices BP Routray and Chittaranjan Dash noted that repeated suicide threats and violent behavior cross the line of emotional outbursts and turn into a “gross misuse of emotional vulnerability” and “psychological warfare”.
“The impact of such behaviour is not limited to the four walls of the matrimonial home. It leaves deep psychological scars, affecting the mental and emotional stability of the spouse,” the bench remarked.
With this, the High Court upheld the family court’s order of marriage dissolution, reaffirming that extreme emotional manipulation and cruelty are valid grounds for divorce.
