Biju Janata Dal (BJD) Rajya Sabha MP and Member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Coal, Mines & Steel, Dr Sasmit Patra, has formally sought urgent clarifications from the National Aluminium Company Limited (NALCO) regarding its proposed 50:50 joint venture with NLC India Limited (NLCIL) for a 1,080 MW captive thermal power project in Angul, Odisha.
In a strongly worded letter addressed today to NALCO Chairman-cum-Managing Director Brijendra Pratap Singh, Dr Patra questioned the commercial rationale behind surrendering half of the project’s equity to another public sector undertaking when NALCO possesses the financial strength, coal reserves, and existing infrastructure to execute the project independently.
Highlighting NALCO’s robust operational capacity—including an existing 1,200 MW captive power plant, established coal linkages, and a production of 4 million tonnes of coal from its Utkal-D and Utkal-E mines in FY 2025–26—the MP argued that the company’s record financial performance warrants a serious evaluation of standalone execution.
NALCO-NLC 50:50 Joint Venture needs further scrutiny.
As a Member of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Coal, Mines & Steel, today I have written to NALCO CMD Shri Bijendra Pratap Singh seeking financial justification for the proposed 50:50 NALCO–NLC joint venture for the 1,080 MW captive power project in Angul, Odisha.
Given NALCO’s existing infrastructure, captive coal, and strong financials, why not execute this independently? I have sought clarity on comparative financials, ownership terms, and safeguards under the 25-year Power Purchase Agreement.— ଡ଼ଃ ସସ୍ମିତ ପାତ୍ର I Dr. Sasmit Patra (@sasmitpatra) November 16, 2026
Citing public concerns and representations received regarding the project—whose estimated cost reportedly ranges between Rs 12,000 crore and Rs 17,000 crore—Dr. Patra called for a point-wise written response backed by techno-economic feasibility reports and Board-approved rationales. His inquiry focuses on six critical areas:
-
Independent Execution: Whether a standalone NALCO-owned model was evaluated against the joint venture, and what comparative assessments proved that giving up 50% equity yields superior financial returns.
-
Financial Justification: Clarity on the approved project cost, comparative financing expenses, projected power tariffs, and lifetime financial benefits under both execution models.
-
Coal Security: Why a separate long-term coal supply arrangement with NLCIL is commercially preferable given NALCO’s captive Utkal-D and Utkal-E mines, alongside questions regarding the operational status of NLCIL’s Machhakata mine.
-
Ownership and Valuation of Assets: What specific value NLCIL brings to justify equal ownership, and how NALCO’s existing land, water, railway connectivity, and ash-handling facilities will be valued and compensated.
-
25-Year Power Purchase Risk: Why NALCO should commit to purchasing 100% of the generated electricity for 25 years while holding only a 50% stake, and what governance and tariff safeguards protect its long-term interests.
-
Project Timelines: The current status of incorporation and approvals, and how timely commissioning will be guaranteed alongside NALCO’s proposed smelter expansion by 2030–31.
Emphasising that a public sector investment of this scale must be driven by demonstrable economic advantage rather than mere inter-PSU convenience, Dr Patra stated that parliamentary oversight is essential to safeguard NALCO’s strategic assets and the long-term economic interests of Odisha.













